
Yesterday’s entry about the Warner Bros. cartoon character, Egghead, sounding like comedian Joe Penner, brought this additional information from Eric Costello:
There’s a character who shot across the footlights like a meteor. Joe Penner died when he was 37 or so (in 1941). His radio career was moderately short by Old Time Radio standards; Rudy Vallee in ‘33, then his own show for NBC Blue, then CBS, then NBC Blue again between 1933 and 1940 (Bill Goodwin, who announced for Bob Hope and Burns & Allen, was one of the announcers). His is a classic case of a personality showing up again and again and again in 1930s cartoons, with little or no chance anyone will recognize him 75 years on. I’ve read that he was popular with kids until the very end.
That’s a picture of Penner above on the left, being hovered over by a very young Ozzie Nelson and Harriet Hilliard, who, of course, would later become Harriet Nelson. Here’s another shot with some other well-known personalities of the day:

From the left, that’s Bob Burns, Tommy Riggs, Charlie McCarthy and his pal, Edgar Bergen, Rudy Vallee and Joe Penner. It’s interesting to note in this picture, Penner is carrying a basket with a duck poking its head out. As the title of this article states, one of his catch-phrases was “Ya wanna buy a duck?” I’m afraid its meaning may be lost to the ages. I don’t know why he was always trying to sell a duck. Maybe someone reading this remembers.
I also want to set the record straight, just for the sake of accuracy, something with which today’s journalists seem to be no longer concerned, and talk more about Egghead’s voice. It seemed to change with the wind, or possibly what actor was available when the cartoon was recorded. In Daffy Duck and Egghead, Cinderella Meets Fella, Count Me Out and Believe It Or Else, he has the Penner voice. In Hamateur Night, Mel Blanc provides his voice as he sings “She’ll Be Comin’ Round the Mountain”. In Egghead Rides Again, Mel again does the voice, sounding like a slightly lower pitched Daffy Duck, complete with lisp. In Johnny Smith and Poker-Huntas, Mel gives us a preview of what Bugs Bunny will sound like in a few years, again slightly lower pitched. It’s Mel once more in A Day at the Zoo, doing Lou Costello’s catch-phrase, “I’m a bad boy!” And in the cartoon mentioned in the other article, A Feud There Was, where Egghead is identified as Elmer Fudd, you can hear Mel’s own speaking voice, though very soft spoken and this time, pitched just a bit higher.
Does anyone know who did the Joe Penner impersonation? It definitely wasn’t Mel Blanc. In fact, in rewatching these cartoons today, there are quite a few other voices besides Mr. Blanc. And while I’m in a questioning mood, “Ya wanna buy a duck?”